People talk
Our Guestbook
“ One of the best Mexican Restaurants. Food is always great along with the service. ”
“ Food is delicious, will definitely be eating here again soon! ”
“ Tucked in the historic downtown Payson this Quant location has yummy food, I enjoy the steak fajitas and making a wish in their indoor fountain. Expert tip - allow an extra hour or two to visit the awesome stores on Utah Avenue. ”
“ Very good food and kind wait staff. The cheese crisp is a must have if you love cheese! A great appetizer! Or have for your meal like I do! ”
“ I always make it in for their Carnitas if I'm in town. The service is indifferent but adequate when i eat in. The prices are fair, and the atmosphere is usually semi festive... worth the trip ”
“ Really good variety of plates. The server was really friendly ”
“ This is one of my families go to places for comfort food. The #34 (chicken enchiladas) is my favorite. I usually don’t like beans and rice but at Mi Rancherito I eat everything that is on my plate. I never have leftovers. Service is always fast and friendly. Another cool thing is the history of the location. The building is historic and has a cool story. ”
“ Delicious, and consistent authentic Mexican food! Kind and efficient staff, cozy environment. The food here is so good and simple in the right way. Feels like going to Abuela's for dinner. Love this place! ”
Menu
Nachos
Camarones Del Golfo
Bean & Pork Burrito
Chicken & Bean Burrito
Bean & Cheese Burrito
About
MI Rancherito Mexican Restaurant
Welcome to the colorful world of MI Rancherito Mexican Restaurant, a cherished dining destination nestled in the heart of historic downtown Payson, Utah. Located at 85 E Utah Ave, this gem offers a delightful experience filled with vibrant flavors, made-from-scratch dishes, and a warm, inviting atmosphere. As a food reviewer for Foodjoyy, my taste buds are excited to take you on a culinary journey through this beloved establishment.
From the moment you step inside MI Rancherito, you're greeted by a festive ambiance and the enticing aroma of authentic Mexican cuisine. The restaurant has received rave reviews from patrons like John Sanders, who declares it "one of the best Mexican Restaurants," emphasizing the consistently great food and service. It's this unwavering dedication to quality that keeps customers coming back for more.
The menu is a treasure trove of delicious options, with highlights such as the steak fajitas, which Troy Kump raves about as "yummy." Prepare to be captivated by the sizzling sounds and fragrant spices that accompany this classic dish, making it a must-try during your visit. Additionally, the cheese crisp, highly recommended by Melanie Kennedy, is a culinary treat that cheese lovers cannot miss. Whether as an appetizer or a meal, its cheesy goodness is sure to win your heart.
For those looking to indulge in something hearty, the Carnitas is another standout, loved by A. Drew Walker, who claims it's a staple when he's in town. This dish embodies the essence of traditional Mexican cooking, offering tender, flavorful meat that speaks volumes about the chef's skill and dedication.
I also appreciated the attentiveness of the staff, who create a welcoming atmosphere, though some might find the service to be "indifferent but adequate." Regardless, the overall experience shines through, offering fair prices that make enjoying quality Mexican fare accessible.
As you visit, don't forget to pause and make a wish at the charming indoor fountain. It's a lovely touch that adds to the restaurant’s unique character. To fully embrace the experience, consider spending some time exploring the vibrant shops along Utah Avenue, as suggested by Troy Kump; a perfect way to enhance your outing.
In summary, MI Rancherito Mexican Restaurant is a delightful culinary oasis in Payson, weaving together tradition, authenticity, and a sprinkle of magic. Whether you're a local or just passing through, make sure to drop by and savor the flavors that keep everyone coming back for more.
Book a table